I just played a little of the Madden 09 demo. The main part of the demo is the Madden Test, which is basically a way for the game to assess your skill as a player, and in doing so it then tailors the games AI to match up with your skill. Which is a great idea on a ton of levels, the problem is that the test doesn’t really test you. Well it test you, but how it doesn’t isn’t neceassirly the best way to be doing it.
For example the rush offense test is basically a test of can you hit the button above your tacklers head, if so you get by. The fact that I can do that has nothing to do with my ability to run the ball offensively in a game situation. They do a little better with passing offense since they introduce almost a full defensive back field for you to deal with, but in the end I found it arbritarily easy compared to how passing actually is in the game.
The defense I guess is probably the only one that is right-ish. It’s still weird in how it doesn’t really translate, but I think its a little fairer in actually testing your skill as compared to the offensive ones.
I should mention that I got All-Madden (hardest difficulty) in both rush and pass offense. Considering I never played above the medium-ish difficulty in Madden and NCAA football, I find that ridiculous. Which is better demonstrated in my defensive test scores that were both rookie.
So EA, its a great idea, but it needs work. Maybe have players play a test game instead of something like this. That seems like it would be a lot better way to gauge the players ability.






